tech-tag

Java on the cell phone part II: 3 Email applications

June 22nd, 2006

With the risc of repeating myself, I will try to deepen the post from yesterday concerning the possibilities for upgrading cell phone with Java applications, and take a deeper look at the email applications as I feel I did not get to the buttum yesterday.

The premises are still, that I’m limited to my Nokia 6610i phone, and the apps which function on that one. Furthermore, there seems to be a significant difference between what the website getjar reports compatible, and what I can’t find compatible (maybe a firmware problem).

I’ve been trying out three applications which I could make work: the hardcore no nonsense email, and the servicebased Flurrymail and Movamail.

Yesterday I was very positive about Simon Judge’s “email”, and I still really like that it takes up so little memory and that it is a fully blown client without the need for signing up for a service. It has however some series limitations. First of all, it does not support html mail. Second I could not make it work with several of my email accounts (including my Gmail), my guess is that this is due to Gmail only accepting encrypted connections. The application serves its purpose, if one can accept these limitations and that the look isn’t “polished”.

Flurrymail is the first of the service based email systems; I covered this in detail yesterday. I will just say that the interface is absolutely excellent. It not only looks, but it seems that everything has been thought through. On signs up very fast with the email address and the password for the email account. I did so with my Gmail account and it worked right away. Adding to this the interface on the phone is very intuitive.
If one goes to the website it is possible to add further email accounts and to news feeds via rss. Yesterday I was very positive about this feature, but I only tried it today. I signed up for my 6-7 favourite feeds, and when I tried it on the phone this morning it turned out that the feeds a shown as emails on the phone. This makes it very hard to find the emails and apparently caused some of my mails to not be loaded to the phone, since I encountered a limit around 60-70 messages. So this is absolutely not a full rss client, I’ve unsubscribed to all the feeds now, and is just using it as a mail client.

Movamail are in some points very similar to Flurrymail, since it is also a service. It just takes a lot longer to sign up, and depending on where you are from in the world it is only free for 60 days. The app looks very well, but I don’t find the control as intuitive as Flurrymail (but this probably differ according to the phone). It is claimed on the website that Movamail is faster than many other apps, I would guess that this should be due to compression, but I do not see this difference in loading times between Movamail and Flurrymail. If any I would say that Flurrymail is the fastest.

After trying the apllications a little more, there is very clear which one I will be using from now on. The limitations in Simon Judge’s email are too big, even though it does count in its favour that it is a complete client. Flurrymail seemed to be the most functional in the interface, both on the website and on my Nokia, and it is free.

That was just my 2 cents let me hear what you have to say.

Entry Filed under: Cell phone, Java Applications, Mobile, email, tech